13,691
edits
Changes
→Cooling
A [[coolship]] is an open vessel used to cool wort by exposure to ambient air which traditional spontaneous fermentation brewers use to both cool their wort and to inoculate the wort with ambient microbes during the open overnight cooling (8-16 hours; extended cooling times of more than a day might lead to mold growth <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/JesterKingBrewery/posts/10154502699393649?comment_id=10154504389923649&reply_comment_id=10154512163043649&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R2%22%7D Thread on Jester King Brewery Facebook thread. 01/16/2017.]</ref>). Traditionally, a coolship is a broad, open-top, flat vessel in which wort cools overnight. The high surface to volume ratio allows for more efficient cooling, which is important at commercial production scales. In addition, this broad, shallow design maximizes the area of wort available for inoculation with ambient microbes. On a homebrew scale, where typical batch sizes cool more quickly, a wide shallow pan is not necessary to achieve appropriate cooling overnight given sufficiently low nighttime outdoor temperatures and the use of a wide shallow pan might result in cooling at a much more rapid rate than seen in traditional commercial production. Boil kettles and similarly shaped vessels are sufficient for overnight cooling for most homebrew batch sizes and may provide a rate of cooling more similar to that provided by coolships in commercial production sized batches <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1068826853145528/ Facebook post by James Howat] </ref>. Cantillon targets a cooled wort temp of 18-20 C (64.4-68 F) after the overnight cooling <ref name="Spontaneous Sour Hour" /> (~50 min in). Traditional producers only carry out spontaneous fermentation between fall and spring when nighttime temperatures have a low of -3.9 to 8°C (25-46°F) to appropriately cool the wort overnight <ref>Conversation between Dave Janssen and Armand Debelder of [[3 Fonteinen]], July 2011</ref><ref name="Spontaneous Sour Hour" />(~39 minutes in, ~54 minutes in). The ambient microbial balance may also be more favorable during this time of year (--some sources say there are more acetic acid bacteria in summer--), but inadequate cooling could result in similar results of enhanced acid production (similar to the effect of warm incubation in [[Wort Souring]], see also [[Spontaneous_Fermentation#Alternative_Applications_of_Spontaneous_Fermentation|Alternative applications of ''Spontaneous Fermentation'']] below). Whatever the root of the different resulting beers based on time of season/ambient nighttime temperature, producers do report different times of year/temperatures exerting a strong influence on the final beer, for example Rob Tod from Allagash Brewing reported solventy and ethyl acetate issues in beers after they were cooled over night at warmer temperatures and aged for 2 years <ref name="Spontaneous Sour Hour" />(~39 minutes in, ~54 minutes in). Russian River Brewing Company reported that cooling the wort before moving it into the coolship results in softer acidity <ref>[https://beerandbrewing.com/podcast-episode-247-spontaneous-brewing-round-table/ Vinnie Cilurzo. Craft Beer and Brewing Magazine Podcast episode #147. 07/12/2022. Retrieved 07/17/2022.]</ref>(~27 mins in).
Some industrial producers of Belgian lambic as well as smaller North American brewers employing spontaneous fermentation acidify their wort to around 4.5 pH before primary fermentation. This was done traditionally by acidifying a portion of wort and adding it to the mash <ref>[https://www.stitcher.com/show/craft-beer-brewing-magazine-podcast/episode/226-for-cantillons-jean-van-roy-brewing-comes-naturally-90577613 Jean Van Roy. Interview with Craft Beer and Beer Magazine Podcast. Episode #226. 02/18/2022.]</ref>(~35 mins in). This may eliminate the enteric bacteria step <ref name="Spitaels et al., 2015" /> (see below, [[Spontaneous_Fermentation#Microbial_Succession_During_Fermentation|Microbial Succession During Fermentation]]). In addition it may act as a safeguard against ''Clostridium botulinum'' (the bacterium responsible for botulism poisoning, which is a serious concern in the food industry because of its high level of toxicity; see [https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/botulism/symptoms-causes/syc-20370262 this Mayo Clinic article]). ''Clostridium botulinum'' can grow at the typical pH range of unfermented and unacidified wort and its spores can survive the boiling process <ref name="James Howat presentation at NHC 2015">[http://www.ahaconference.org/seminars/wild-and-spontaneous-fermentation-at-home James Howat presentation at NHC 2015]</ref>. The degree of botulism risk is not known, though if any reported cases of botulism poisoning from beer exist they are not known to us. Traditional lambic producers have been fermenting unacidified and spontaneously inoculated wort for decades to centuries, which suggests that the risk, if it does exist at all, is very small when following traditional lambic production methods. Furthermore, hops have antimicrobial properties against gram positive bacteria <ref>[http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168160503001533/ Sakamoto and Konings, 2003. Beer spoilage bacteria and hop resistance.]</ref> and ''Clostridium botulinum'' is gram positive <ref>[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clostridium_botulinum/ Clostridium botulinum Wikipedia page]</ref>. Hop acids might also partially inhibit ''Clostridium botulinum'' and some other gram-positive pathogens <ref>[https://patents.google.com/patent/US6251461B1/en Antimicrobial activity of hops extract against Clostridium botulinum, Clostridium difficile and Helicobacter pylori. Eric A. Johnson and Gerhard J. Haas. Google Patents (expired). Filed 1997-10-10. Retrieved 05/27/2022.]</ref>. Some suggest eliminating any potential worry of botulism by acidifying your wort before inoculation <ref name="James Howat presentation at NHC 2015">[http://www.ahaconference.org/seminars/wild-and-spontaneous-fermentation-at-home James Howat presentation at NHC 2015]</ref><ref>[http://suigenerisbrewing.blogspot.com/2017/01/fact-of-fiction-can-pathogens-survive.html "Fact of Fiction - Can Pathogens Survive in Beer? The RDWHAHB Edition". Bryan of Sui Generis Blog. 01/05/2017. Retrieved 01/16/2017.]</ref>. Whether or not this protects from botulism, it will influence the final beer by preventing enteric bacteria growth. In addition, acidifying may influence the activity of ''Pediococcus'' in a spontaneously fermented beer, including the development of "sick" beer, and may therefore alter the final beer (acidic conditions can trigger exopolysaccharide production in some strains of lactic acid bacteria; see [[Pediococcus#.22Ropy.22_or_.22Sick.22_Beer|''Pediodoccus'']]) <ref name="Spontaneous Sour Hour" /> (~1:10 in).
The presence of at least 2-5 ppm of dissolved oxygen (DO) in the wort might also reduce the risk of botulism <ref name="Pérez-Fuentetaja">[https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10750-005-0011-1 Influence of Limnological Conditions on Clostridium Botulinum Type E Presence in Eastern Lake Erie Sediments (Great Lakes, USA). Alicia Pérez-Fuentetaja, Mark D. Clapsadl, Donald Einhouse, Paul R. Bowser, Rodman G. Getchell, W. Theodore Lee. 2006.]</ref>(more references needed); however, the levels of DO in wort that has been cooled in a coolship has not been well studied, and neither has the amount of DO during the first few days of fermentation. Dissolved oxygen in wort that is near boiling temperatures will be limited due to Hentry's law, but some amount of atmospheric oxygen will be absorbed as the wort cools over night <ref>[https://www.boundless.com/physiology/textbooks/boundless-anatomy-and-physiology-textbook/respiratory-system-22/gas-laws-210/henry-s-law-1032-977/ "Henry's Law". Bouldess.com website. Retrieved 03/07/2017.]</ref><ref>[http://docs.engineeringtoolbox.com/documents/639/oxygen-solubility-water-2.png Graph of oxygen solubility in water at different temperatures. Engineering Toolbox website. Retrieved 03/07/2017.]</ref><ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1599584193403122/?comment_id=1599693336725541&reply_comment_id=1600361503325391&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R%22%7D Bryan of Sui Generis blog. MTF discussion on dissolved oxygen in wort cooled in a coolship, and the accuracy of DO meters. 03/02/2017.]</ref>. Some reports of DO in wort cooled in a coolship MTF include ~4 ppm in a small coolship that was 2' x 1' x 1', and 3.6 - 3.8 ppm in wort cooled overnight in an open 10 gallon boil kettle <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/browse/likes?id=1605741916120683 Amaral, Justin. MTF discussion on dissolved oxygen in coolship wort. 03/07/2017.]</ref>. The DO levels from a commercial sized coolship (10 BBL; 6' x 10') were reportedly 2.6 ppm after the transfer to the coolship while the wort was still hot, and 5.1 ppm after the wort cooled for 14 hours <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1601687793192762/?comment_id=1601698063191735&reply_comment_id=1602191886475686&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R1%22%7D Coker, Ryan. MTF discussion on dissolved oxygen in wort cooled in a commercial coolship. 03/07/2017.]</ref>. The dissolved oxygen levels could increase during the filling of the barrels, although there is no data on this that we know of currently. The dissolved oxygen in the wort, however, could be quickly consumed by aerobic bacteria and yeast (which then generally produce a low pH environment that is hostile to ''Clostridium botulinum''). Additionally, some strains of ''C. botulinum'' are more oxygen tolerant than others. Therefore, DO levels should not be relied upon for preventing botulism. Instead, either a timely fermentation is desirable (within 4 days has been a suggestion; however, it is not known how long it would take ''C. botulism'' to grow in anaerobic wort and produce enough botulism toxin <ref>[http://beerandwinejournal.com/botulism/ "Storing Wort Runs the Risk of Botulism". Dr. Colby, Chris. Beer and Wine Journal blog. 04/17/2014. Retrieved 03/07/2017.]</ref>, or reducing the pH below 5 before the wort is cooled or immediately after <ref name="Pérez-Fuentetaja" /><ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1604630206231854/?comment_id=1605313322830209&reply_comment_id=1605352169492991&comment_tracking=%7B%22tn%22%3A%22R%2312%22%7D Bryan Heit of Sui Generis Blog. MTF discussion on dissolved oxygen in wort cooled in a coolship. 03/07/2017.]</ref>.