Difference between revisions of "Brettanomyces"

Revision as of 20:35, 15 May 2016

Brettanomyces

Brett Aroma Wheel by Dr. Linda Bisson and Lucy Joseph at UC Davis

Brettanomyces, also referred to by brewers as "Brett" or "Bretta", is a yeast that was originally thought of as a spoilage yeast. The genus name Dekkera is used interchangeably with Brettanomyces, as it describes the teleomorph or spore forming form of the yeast ^[1]. Known for it's barnyard, fecal, horsey, metallic or Band-Aid flavors, Brettanomyces was unwelcome in most breweries. However, in some styles like Saison and Lambic these flavors add a layer of complexity to the beer. Brettanomyces can form a pellicle. See Lactobacillus, Pediococcus, Saccharomyces, and Mixed Cultures charts for other commercially available cultures.

Introduction of Characteristics

Brettanomyces was first discovered by Hjelte Claussen in 1903. At the time of discovery, Claussen was aiming to recreate the flavor profile of traditional English ales by fermenting them with pure cultures of Saccharomyces, and either pitching pure cultures of his newly discovered Brettanomyces yeast along with Saccharomyces, or as he preferred, after the primary fermentation of Saccharomyces ^[2]. Although Claussen saw the character from Brettanomyces as a desirable character in ales and identified its character as a quality of traditional English ales, at some point Brettanomyces became identified as a contaminate in wineries and breweries due to some of the phenols that it sometimes produces. These have generally been described as barnyard, burnt plastic, wet animal, fecal, and horse sweat ^[3]. The general viewpoint of brewers (other than Lambic and Flanders red/brown brewers in Belgium) and vintners that Brettanomyces is primarily a spoilage organism held for many decades, and still holds in most cases. More recently the positive flavor components that have been identified in Brettanomyces beer such as pineapple, stone fruits, and to some degree acetic acid, have regained popularity with brewers outside of Belgium.

Brettanomyces has been identified on the skins of fruit ^[3], as well as vectors (insects) ^[4]. Brettanomyces is not considered to be airborne, however studies have found a very small amount of cells in the air at wineries where wine with Brettanomyces in it was being handled (most of the yeasts found in the air were Aureobasidium and Cryptococcus, which aren't considered spoilage organisms in beer and wine). These set of studies also determined that very specific methodology was needed in order capture Brett from the air, and indicated that the yeast was "stressed". ^[5]. While it is possible for Brettanomyces to be briefly carried by gusts of air, it only happens in the vicinity where the Brettanomyces beer or wine is being bottled (more so) or is actively fermenting (less so). Good cleaning and sanitation, and cold temperatures should be employed to keep Brettanomyces from infecting other equipment, and flying insects are a more likely cause for cross contamination of Brettanomyces.

It is common in scientific literature to see the names Dekkera and Brettanomyces used as the genus name, with Dekkera being the teleomorph version and Brettanomyces being the anamorph. There are five species within the genus of Brettanomyces: B. anomola, B. bruxellensis, B. custersianus, B. nanus, and B. naardenensis. Of these five species, only B. anomola and B. bruxellensis have been identified to have a teleomorph version. In their teleomorph version they are referred to as Dekkera anomola and Dekkera bruxellensis ^[3]. All of the other names such as the ones often used by yeast labs are derived by old nomenclature that is no longer used. The addition of small amounts of O2 stimulates glucose fermentation, as well as H+ acceptors such as acetaldehyde, acetone, pyruvic acid and other carbonyl compounds ^[6].

Unlike most genres of yeast, Brettanomyces has the characteristics of being very tolerant to high amounts of alcohol, a pH as low as 2 ^[7], and low nitrogen sources ^[3]. Perhaps the most differentiating characteristic of Brettanomyces is its preference to ferment glucose in the presence of oxygen, which is the opposite preference in Saccharomyces. This was initially dubbed the "negative Pasteur effect" by Custers, and later the "Custers effect" ^[6].

Sulfite and SO₂ inhibits the growth of Brettanomyces ^[8].

Brettanomyces Metabolism

Carbohydrate Metabolism

Brettanomyces is able to ferment a wide range of sugars. All strains can ferment glucose, and many strains can ferment sucrose, fructose, and maltose, although at a slower rate than glucose. Some strains can also ferment galactose ^[4].

Brettanomyces strains may possess both alpha and beta glucosidases. These enzymes allow Brettanomyces strains to break down a broad range of sugars, including longer chain carbohydrate molecules (polysaccharides, dextrins, and cellulose/cellobiose), and to liberate glycosidically bound sugars which are unfermentable to Saccharomyces yeasts. ^[4]^[9].

Extracellular and intracellular alpha-glucosidase activity has been shown to break down sugars up to 9 carbons in one strain of B. lambicus, which is partly responsible for the over-attenuation of wort that some strains of Brettanomyces an achieve ^[6]. Alpha glucosidases are the enzymes that allow them to break down maltose, turanose, melezitose, and trehalose, as well as dextrins such as maltotetraose and maltopentaose. These dextrins are left over after a normal Saccharomyces fermentation ^[4]. Some polysaccharides can be fermented by Brettanomyces, including starch, laminarin, and pectin ^[10].

Beta-glycosidases can break down the beta-glycosidic bond in disaccharides (cellulose, cellobiose, and gentiobiose) ^[11], as well as glycosides. Glycosides are sugar molecules connected to other organic compounds such as acids, alcohols, and aldehydes which are flavor and aroma inactive due to the sugar molecule attached. By cleaving off the sugar molecule through beta-glucosidase activity, Brettanomyces species can liberate these compounds (called aglycones) into their aroma-active and flavor-active states, or states that may become flavor and aroma active through further modification ^[12]. Therefore Brettanomyces strains are able to produce novel flavors and aromas from hops, fruits, and fruit pits that Saccharomyces yeasts cannot produce. In addition, the liberated aroma and flavor active compounds may be further processed by Brettanomyces through ester production or destruction pathways. See Beta-Glucosidase Activity for more information.

There is a highly genetic diversity between strains of Brettanomyces species, both in a genotypic and phenotypic sense ^[10]. Not all species are capable of consuming the same types of sugars. For example, B. anomalus (aka claussenii) are generally able to ferment lactose, but B. bruxellensis is generally not. Different strains within the same species may not be able to ferment the same types of sugars ^[13]^[14]. For example, some strains are not able to ferment maltose, which is almost half the sugar content of wort ^[15]. Such strains would not be a good choice for 100% Brettanomyces fermentation.

The ability of a given Brettanomyces strain to ferment different types of sugars might be at least partially linked to its source of isolation. For example, a strain of B. bruxellensis isolated from a soft drink could not ferment the disaccharides maltose, turanose, or the trisaccharide melezitose, whereas all of the other B. bruxellensis strains isolated from beer and wine could ferment these disaccharides/trisaccharide. The beer strains, however, were unable to ferment cellobiose or gentiobiose, as well as arbutin and methyl-gluoside. The wine strains were able to ferment these disaccharides, perhaps because they were adapted to the environment in which they were isolated from (wine barrels) ^[10].

Currently, research into how well Brettanomyces strains ferment the trisaccharide maltotriose has not been explored much by science, however one study found that B. custersianus can ferment maltotriose. Another study found that all 7 strains of B. bruxellensis tested could ferment maltotriose, but not the trisaccharide raffinose. More investigation into this possibility is needed ^[16]^[10]. The below table is an example of the variety of sugar types that different strains/species of Brettanomyces banked at the National Collection of Yeast Cultures can ferment:

Species ^[14]	NCYC Num	Glucose	Sucrose	Maltose	Cellobiose	Lactose	Soluble Starch	Glycerol	Ethanol	Lactic Acid	Succinic Acid	Citric Acid
D. anomala	NCYC 2	+	+	+	+	+	-	-	Weak/Latent	-	-	-
B. anomalus	NCYC 749	+	+	-	+	+	-	Weak/Latent	Latent	-	-	-
B. anomalus	NCYC 615	+	+	+	+	+	Unknown	+	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown
D. anomala	NCYC 449	+	+	-	+	+	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown
B. bruxellensis	NCYC 2818	+	+	+	-	-	-	-	+	-	-	-
D. bruxellensis	NCYC 2263	Weak/Latent	Weak/Latent	Weak/Latent	Weak/Latent	-	Weak/Latent	-	Weak/Latent	Weak/Latent	-	-
D. bruxellensis	NCYC 1559	+	+	-	+	-	-	+	+	-	-	-
D. bruxellensis	NCYC 823	+	+	+	-	-	-	-	-	-	-	Unknown
D. bruxellensis	NCYC 395	+	+	+	-	-	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown
B. bruxellensis	NCYC 370	+	+	+	-	-	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown
B. bruxellensis	NCYC 362	+	+	+	-	-	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Unknown
B. naardenensis	NCYC 3450	+	Unknown	-	+	-	-	-	Weak/Latent	Weak/Latent	-	-
B. naardenensis	NCYC 3015	+	-	Weak/Latent	+	-	+	-	+	+	-	-
B. naardenensis	NCYC 924	+	-	+	+	-	Weak/Latent	-	+	Weak/Latent	-	-
B. naardenensis	NCYC 899	+	-	Weak/Latent	Weak/Latent	-	-	-	Weak/Latent	Weak/Latent	-	Unknown
B. naardenensis	NCYC 813	+	-	+	+	-	Unknown	-	+	Weak/Latent	+	Unknown

Glycosides and Beta-Glucosidase Activity

(This section is in progress)

Monoterpenes and Glycosides

Monoterpenes generally exist as aromatic and flavorful alcohols that tend to smell floral with low odor thresholds (100-400 ppb), and are present in plant material. These alcohols mostly consist of linalool (a major contributor to hop aroma ^[17]), geraniol, nerol, and linalool oxides, but also includes other monoterpenes such as citronellol, alpha-terpineol, hotrienol, nerol oxide, myrcenol, the ocimenols, and other oxides, aldehydes and hydrocarbons. In wine (and probably sour beer), these alcohols bind with acids to create aromatic monoterpene ethyl esters and acetate esters, and can also be transformed into other types of monoterpenes by yeast metabolism ^[18]^[19]. Monoterpenes can also be odorless polyols, some of which can break down easily to produce pleasant aromas. For example, diendiol can break down into hotrienol (tropical, floral, fennel, ginger aroma ^[20]) and nerol oxide (green, vegetative and floral with a minty undernote ^[21]). It is thought that some strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae might be able to produce monoterpenes such as geraniol during fermentation in ways not related to beta-glucosidase activity ^[22].

Glycosides are a very diverse group of non-volatile and flavorless molecules that generally encompass any molecule that has a sugar bound to a non-sugar molecule (thus separating them from polysaccharides). The sugar (monosaccharide or oligosaccharide) component of the molecule is known as the "glycone", and the non-sugar component is known as the "aglycone". By breaking the glycosidic bond of a glycoside, the aglycone component is released. The aglycone component of glycosides are often polyphenols or the floral monoterpene alcohols described above. Glycosides can be categorized based on their glycone (glucose vs fructose), type of glycosidic bond (α-glycosides or β-glycosides), or by their aglycone (alcoholic, anthraquinone, coumarin, cyanogenic, flavonoid, phenolic, aponins, steroidal/cardiac, steviol, or thioglycosides). Glycosides play important roles in living organisms, especially many types of plants which store glycosides in their tissue and then break the bond between the sugar and non-sugar aglycone when the aglycone is needed for certain biological functions ^[23]. These include protecting cells from toxins in the plant and attracting insects via the fragrance of flowers ^[24].

Aglycones have been identified in many fruits and herbs such as grapes, apricots, peaches, yellow plums, quince, sour cherry, passion fruit, kiwi, papaya, pineapple, mango, lulo, raspberry, strawberry, and tea ^[25]^[24]. They have been found in different parts of plants, including the green leafy parts, fruit, roots, rhizomes, petals, and seeds. Aglycones in plants are highly complex structures and very diverse, and their percentages can vary from crop to crop. In plants, these include terpenols, terpenes, linalool oxides, as well as other flavor precursors including various alcohols, norisoprenoids, phenolic acids and probably volatile phenols such as vanillin. In many cases of fruit, the amount of aromatic aglycones that are bound up in glycosides out number the amount that are free in a ratio of 2:1 to 8:1 ^[25]. Aglycones that are bound up in glycosides tend to be more water soluble and less reactive once unbound than the naturally free version. By providing enzymes that break the glicosidic bond, discarded parts of plants (peels, stems, skins, etc.) have been used to produce natural flavorings from the remaining and abundant glycosides ^[24].

Beta-Glucosidase

Aglycones can be released from glycosides by either exposure to acid (generally pH of 3 or lower, and different pH's giving different results on which glycosides are broken down; this breakdown of glycosides under low pH has been linked to the slow flavor development of aging wine ^[25]), or by enzymes called beta-glycosidases. Enzymatic breakdown of glycosides as been described as producing a more "natural" flavor in wines versus acidic breakdown. Some fruits have been observed (mostly wine grapes) to have limited beta-glucosidase activity within themselves, however it has been observed as being unstable and having low activity at the low pH of wine and sour beer ^[25].

Beta-glycosidase enzymes can be added artificially, however there has been much interest in the natural capability of microorganisms to produce beta-glycosidases ^[24]. Microorganisms that can break down glycosides by using beta-glucosidases can then access the resulting sugars for fermentation ^[4]. There are two major categories of glucosidase activity: endogenous and exogenous. Endogenous enzymatic activity takes place inside of the cell, and exogenous enzymatic activity takes place outside of the cell. Bacteria and fungi that show endogenous glucosidase activity have been shown not to be effective in alcoholic fermentation due to not tolerating low pH (optimum pH of 5), glucose, and/or ethanol. Generally, the flavorless glycosides remain unaffected by yeast fermentation, leaving them unused as a potential source for flavor and aroma ^[24].

Exogenous beta-glycosidase activity has been shown to be much more effective at releasing aglycones from glycosides in bacteria and fungi. For glycosides which contain a glucose, which is the majority, beta-glucosidase cleaves the sugar, thus releasing the aglycone. For glycosides that contain disaccharides, usually another enzyme must be present to first break down the disaccharide before the beta-glucosidase can release the aglycone (beta-xylosidase, alpha-arabinosidase, alpha-rhamnosidase, or beta-apiosidase) ^[24]. However, glycosides in tea leaves that contain disaccharide sugars (cellulose/cellobiose ^[11]) have been observed to be broken down without the use of these other enzymes; the beta-glucosidase cleaves the aglycone from the disaccharide on its own. Some species of yeast (Debaryomyces castelli, D. hansenii, D. polymorphus, Kloeckera apiculata, Hansenula anomala, and Brettanomyces spp), bacteria (Oenococcus oeni), and fungi (Aspergillus niger) have been found to have strain dependent beta-glucosidase activity, however several inhibitors for glucosidase activity vary for different strains of microbes. These inhibitors include the presence of glucose, pH, temperature, ethanol, and phenols ^[25]^[26]. For example, for some strains of O. oeni, as little as 10mg/L of glucose is enough to inhibit beta-glucosidase activity, or the presence of alcohol or typical wine pH (3.0 - 4.0) was enough to inhibit. Other strains of O. oeni are not inhibited by some or all of these inhibitors ^[27].

Activity of Brettanomyces and Saccharomyces

One study screened the beta-glucosidase activity of several strains of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Saccharomyces pastorianus, and Brettanomyces spp ^[28]. None of the lager brewing strains showed beta-glucosidase activity. Out of 32 strains of S. cerevisiae, only one strain (a wine strain called "U228") showed beta-glucosidase activity, however its activity was repressed in the presence of glucose. This indicates that most S. cerevisiae strains do not have the capability of producing beta-glucosidase, but it is possible that some very few strains can ^[28]. However, beta-glucosidase activity for S. cerevisiae is inhibited by pH levels of wine and sour beer (optimal at pH 5) ^[26]. All strains of S. cerevisiae did release another enzyme called beta-glucanase, which led to varying degrees of breaking down some smaller glycosides found in hops containing the aglycones methyl salicylate, 1-octen-3-ol, and cis-3-hexen-1-ol, but not linalool. None of the B. bruxellensis strains showed this activity, but the only tested strain of B. custersianus and both of the B. anomala strains tested did show cell-associated (endogenous) beta-glucosidase activity. In particular, the B. custersianus strain was tested against glycosides from hops, in which case high amounts of the algycones linalool (citrus, orange, lemon, floral ^[29]), methyl salicylate (minty, wintergreen ^[30]), 1-octen-3-ol (mushroom, earthy ^[31]) and cis-3-hexen-1-ol (grassy, melon rind ^[32]) were released ^[28]. The beta-glucosidase activity was elevated when co-fermenting B. custersianus with S. cerevisiae. The authors also found dihydroedulan 1 and 2 (elderberry aroma) and theaspirane A and B (woody and campfire aromas), which are classified as norisoprenoids, were released from dry hopping ^[33]. B. custersianus has been isolated from the later stages of lambic fermentation, and it is thought that its ability to produce beta-glucosidase, which gives it the ability to ferment cellobiose and cellotriose, is a possible adaptation from living in oak barrels ^[28].

The same strain of B. custersianus was screened for beta-glucosidase activity and aglycone byproducts during the refermentation of sour cherries in beer (a very small amount of the byproducts were manufactured by the yeast de novo, particularly linalool, alpha-terpineol, alpha-ionol, and a precursor that leads to beta-damascenone under low pH conditions). Different portions of the cherries were tested: whole cherries with stones (pits), cherry pulp without stones, cherry juice without stones or other solids from the fruit, and the stones alone. Benzaldehyde (almond, cherry stone flavor) was produced during fermentation in all cases, and reduced to benzyl alcohol (almond flavor) and benzyl acetate (fruity, jasmin flavor) by the end of fermentation. There were higher levels of these benzyl based compounds in the whole cherries and cherry stone alone samples, indicating that cherry stones make a big impact on the almond flavors found in cherry sour beers. Methyl salicylate, linalool, alpha-terpineol (pine), geraniol (rose, lime, floral) and alpha-ionol (floral, violet), eugenol (spicy, clove, medicinal) and isoeugenol (fine delicate clove) levels increased in all forms of cherries added except for stones alone, indicating that these aglycones are more present in the flesh and juice of the cherries ^[19].

Many strains of B. bruxellensis have also been found to have varying degrees of intracellular (endogenous) beta-glucosidase activity. Brettanomyces has more strains that can produce beta-glucosidase than other genre of yeast, and the strains generally also have a higher rate of beta-glucosidase activity than other genre of yeast ^[34]^[26]. Some Brettanomyces strains may only be capable of beta-glucosidase activity, and not the other enzymes which are needed to break down disaccharide type glycosides. Additionally, cell death and autolysis can result in an increase in beta-glucosidase activity in solution due to the cell contents being released into solution ^[26].

Secondary Metabolites

Secondary metabolites are compounds that are not essential to the life of an organism ^[35]. Brettanomyces will use a range of secondary metabolites to produce many of the fruity and funky esters, phenols, and acids that this genus of yeast has become known for.

Ester Production

Brettanomyces is capable of synthesizing several ethyl esters from ethanol and fatty acids. Among the most prolific of these are ethyl acetate, ethyl lactate and phenethyl acetate, along with the hydrolysis (breakdown) of isoamyl acetate. During non-mixed fermentations where lactic acid is minimal to none, insignificant amounts of ethyl lactate ester is produced, whereas ethyl caprylate and ethyl caproate have a general increase. With the addition of lactic acid, ethyl lactate levels are greatly increased although may still not reach the flavor threshold level of 250 mg/L (strain dependent), and ethyl acetate is generally slightly increased. The amounts of esters produced varies widely based on species and strain ^[36]. A similar but slower evolution of esters has been seen in a long term study on examining how Belgian lambic from Cantillon ages in bottles. The study found that lactic acid (produced by lactic acid bacteria) and ethyl lactate increased as bottles aged, while ethyl decanoate and isoamyl acetate decreased, all presumably from Brettanomyces metabolism over time ^[37].

Ester production peaks towards the end of growth, and is influenced by temperature, aeration/agitation, and pH. Spaepen and Verachtert found in one study that the optimal temperature for growth and thus ester production was 28°C (77°F), although they did not test higher temperatures. This study also found that continuously shaken samples produced relatively less esters, as well as samples that were not exposed to oxygen at all. The highest ester production was found under conditions of limited oxygen supply, no agitation, held at a temperature of 28°C (77°F), and young cells produced more esters than older cells. It also found that esterase activity (esterase is the enzyme that facilitates ester production and destruction) increases as pH rises until a pH of 7.6 is reached, after which it begins to decline again. It was shown that the ester formation/degradation was indeed caused by enzymatic activity of any Brettanomyces species/strain, and not caused by chemical reactions or from Saccharomyces or Kloeckera activity ^[38]. Pitching rate of Brettanomyces may have a slight effect on ester production levels, but the differences caused by pitching rate probably do not have a significant impact on sensory character of the beer ^[39].

Esters are also broken down via a process called hydrolysis. Hydrolysis breaks the esters down using the same esterase enzyme within the Brettanomyces cells that is used to create esters. In general, all acetate based esters, except for phenethyl acetate and methyl acetate, are broken down faster than non-acetate esters by Brettanomyces. In lambic brewing, some time after the primary fermentation finishes, Pediococcus begins to produce lactic acid. The formation of lactic acid by Pediococcus coincides with the appearance and growth of Brettanomyces, which produces more acetic acid. After another 2-3 months, the ester content of the lambic beer changes and reaches an equilibrium. Ethyl acetate and ethyl lactate are greatly increased, while isoamyl acetate is greatly decreased, reaching an equilibrium of these esters. Given a static amount of acetic acid, Brettanomyces reaches equilibrium of ethyl acetate within 24 hours, while ethyl lactate equilibrium takes longer and is much more complex. In lambic, the majority of ester production and breakdown occurs within 1-3 months after lactic acid production by Pediococcus begins, and at a pH of around 3.5 and a temperature of around 15°C or less ^[38]. Pitching rate of Brettanomyces has an effect on the breakdown of isoamyl acetate with higher pitching rates breaking down this ester at a faster rate ^[39].

Phenol Production

Phenols such as 4-vinylphenol (4VP, barnyard, medicinal) and 4-vinylguaiacol (4-VG, clove) can be produced in beer by the decarboxylation of hydroxycinnamic acids, which are found in malt. While both Saccharomyces (only by "phenolic off flavor positive/POF+" strains) and Brettanomyces strains are have varying capabilities based on strain of converting hydroxycinnamic acids to their vinyl derivatives ^[74], Brettanomyces is also able to reduce these vinyl derivatives to ethyl derivatives. These vinyl derivatives have similar tastes to the ethyl derivatives but have lower flavor thresholds. Levels of all compounds produced vary depending on species and strain of Brettanomyces. Some data supports that pitching rate does not have an effect on how much phenol content is produced by Brettanomyces^[39]. This contradicts the somewhat popular belief that under-pitching Brettanomyces produces more "funky" flavors.

Acid Production

In the presence of oxygen, Brettanomyces strains are capable of producing acetic acid. Depending on the brewer's palate and the degree of acetic production, this can be a desirable or undesirable trait. The degree of acetic acid production varies among different Brettanomyces strains. Acetic acid produced by Brettanomyces may also be used in the synthesis of acetate esters such as ethyl acetate. Brettanomyces has been shown to produce enough fatty acids in anaerobic fermentation to drop the pH to 4.0, which can also be esterified (see the ester table above) ^[44]. Many of these acids can have an unpleasant rancid odor and/or taste, which may be noticeable in young Brettanomyces beers before these acids are esterified.

Michael Lentz and Chad Harris tested whether or not the hydroxycinnamic acids (HCAs) inhibit the growth of Brettanomyces. They found that high levels of hydroxycinnamic acids (HCAs), which includes ferulic acid, p-coumaric acid, and caffeic acid, do inhibit the growth of Brettanomyces. Ferulic acid is the strongest inhibitor of these three HCAs with most strains tested not being able to grow in wort that contained 12 mM (millimolar) of ferulic acid. Caffeic acid was generally shown to be the weakest inhibitor of the three HCAs tested. Levels of 25 mM p-courmaric acid inhibited growth of all strains tested, and levels of 30 mM of caffeic acid inhibited all strains tested. The ability of HCAs to inhibit growth is different from strain to strain of Brettanomyces. Inhibition does not appear to be species dependent. Some strains display a lag time and grow more slowly in the presence of high amounts of HCA's, but still eventually achieve maximum growth compared to if they were grown without exposure to HCAs, while others lag and then stop growing before reaching maximum growth ^[74].

The amount of HCAs varies widely from plant to plant, and the amount that is found in must or wort also varies on how the raw ingredients are treated. These measurements are generally not a consideration for maltsters or grape growers ^[74]. The one exception to this is the ferulic acid rest that German brewers have used to create more clove-like flavors in certain beer styles.

Acids Produced	Precursors	Notes
Acetic Acid (Vinegar, hard boiled egg)	Oxygen	Increased production with higher levels of oxygen exposure ^[44].
Isovaleric Acid (Feety, parmesian) ^[91]^[92]	Leucine	Commonly described as a "spoilage" acid produced by Brettanomyces in wine, but also appears in beer.
Caproic acid (Fatty, cheesy, waxy, barnyardy) ^[44]		Fatty acid.
Enanthic acid (Rancid odor) ^[44]		Fatty acid.
Caprylic acid (Rancid-like smell and taste ^[44]		Fatty acid. Also found in milk. Gives a waxy/oily mouthfeel. Flavor is more intense at low pH levels. Also called octanoic acid.^[93]
Pelargonic acid (Rancid odor) ^[44]		Fatty acid.
Capric acid (Barnyard animal odor/taste) ^[44]		Fatty acid. Also found in milk, coconut oil, and seed oils ^[94].
Undecylic acid ^[44]		Fatty acid.
Lauric acid (faint odor of bay oil or soap) ^[44]		Fatty acid.

Other Compounds

Compound Produced	Precursors	Threshold	Notes
Tetrahydropyridine (cheerios, mousy, urine, cracker biscuit)	L-Lysine, ethanol, and oxygen	Varies	See the Tetrahydropyridine page for more details. Classified as a ketone ^[95].

Commercial Cultures

Pure cultures. In cooperation with Funk Factory.

Bootleg Biology

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Funk Weapon #1 BB0034A	This rare, and commercially unavailable yeast isolate, produces pungent horse blanket and fresh leather aromas. Perfect for breaking out the funk in farmhouse-style beers. This is the first release in the Dusty Bottoms Collection’s ongoing Funk Weapon Series of unique, rare Brettanomyces and Brett-like wild yeast cultures.	West Flanders, Belgium brewery specializing in funky, sour, mixed-fermentation beers.
Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	Funk Weapon #2 BB0035C	This rare, and commercially unavailable yeast isolate is perfect for 100% Brettanomyces fermentations, especially Brett IPAs. Amplifies citrus and tropical fruit-forward hop flavors and aromas into a punchy ripeness. Great for maintaining the nuance of hops in beer with greater keeping qualities than a Brewer’s Yeast fermentation. You can’t make every style of beer with one or two strains of brewer’s yeast, so why would you only use only one or two strains for your funky beers? This is the second release in the Dusty Bottoms Collection’s ongoing Funk Weapon Series of unique, rare Brettanomyces and Brett-like wild yeast cultures.	Family-owned brewery producing Gueuze in West Flanders, Belgium.

Brewing Science Institute

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Brettanomyces bruxellensis	Medium intensity Brett character. Classic strain used in secondary fermentation for Belgian style beers and lambics.	Same as White Labs. Pro-Brewers only.
Claussenii	Dekkera anomala	B. claussenii	Brettanomyces clausenii	Low intensity Brett character.	Same as White Labs. Pro-Brewers only.
CMY1	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis CMY1	bsi		Chad Yakobson's mutation of BSI Drie. Pro-Brewers only.
Drie	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. drei	Brettanomyces bruxellensis var. Drei	Highly aromatic brett strain. Sourness takes extensive aging to produce	Isolate from Drie Fonteinen; Pro-Brewers only. Recommended fermentation levels to get the most character out of Drie include 75-77°F ^[96].
Lambicus	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. lambicus	Brettanomyces lambicus	High intensity Brett character. Know to produce the “horsey” aroma characteristic of Brettanomyces yeast. Classic strain used in secondary fermentation for Belgian style beers and lambics. Same as White Labs.	Pro-Brewers only.

East Coast Yeast

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Anomala	Dekkera anomala	B. intermedius	ECY-04	strong ester profile with some light funk and acidity	beer - Adelaide, Australia
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	ECY-05	funky with barnyard notes accompanied by some fruit	isolated from Belgian stout
Custersianus	Brettanomyces custersianus	B. custersianus	ECY-19	light fruit and hay	Bantu beer brewery, South Africa
Farmhouse	?	B. fantome	ECY-03b	Fruity and funky profile with some acidity gradually increasing over time. Aeration has more of a muted effect	Isolate from Fantome. May not be Brett as per Lance Shaner on MTF.
Naardenensis	Brettanomyces naardenensis	B. naardenensis	ECY-30	strawberry, honey, ripe fruit with a tart, citrusy acidity after 6mo of aging	Isolated from Dr. Pepper
Nanus	Eeniella nana	B. nanus	ECY-24	spicy, saison-like profile	bottled beer - Kalmar, Sweden

Escarpment Laboratories

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Brett B	A classic Brettanomyces bruxellensis strain, typically used in secondary fermentations. Attenuation: 70-85% // Optimum Temp: 26ºC+ (80F+) // Alcohol tolerance: Medium-high // Flocculation: Low
Claussenii	Dekkera anomala	B. claussenii	Brett C	A strain of Brettanomyces clausenii, now understood to be among the Brettanomyces anomala species. Minimal funk, tends to exhibit fruity pineapple or mango notes. Pairs well with fruit and/or hops. Recommended for secondary or co-fermentation as attenuation is variable. Attenuation: Highly Variable // Optimum Temp: 18-25ºC (64.4-77F) // Flocculation: Medium-low
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Brett D	This strain of Brettanomyces bruxellensis is a notoriously vigorous fermentor, suitable for primary fermentation of 100% Brett beers or secondary fermentation where some extra funk is desired. Attenuation: 80+% // Optimum Temp: 20-25ºC (68-77ºF) // Alcohol tolerance: 12%+ // Flocculation: Medium-low
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Brett Q	This strain typically completes primary fermentation within one month, and is also suitable for secondary aging of a wide range of beer styles where subtle Brett character is desired. Tasting notes include ripe strawberry, pear, apple, with underlying funk. Attenuation: 80%+ // Optimum Temp: 20-25ºC // Alcohol tolerance: High // Flocculation: Medium-low	Originally isolated from a barrel-aged sour beer from Quebec.

Inland Island Brewing & Consulting

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	INIS-901 Brettanomyces bruxellensis I	Isolated from a brewery in Brussels this particular Brettanomyces strain in known for producing aromatics reminiscent of horse, barnyard, sweat, and goat. It is highly attenuative and will take up to 6 months to fully finish fermentation. It is suggested that this strain be used with another primary fermentation strain. 90% + Attenuation. Low Flocculation. 60-75 F Temperature Range. High Alcohol Tolerance.	Brewery in Brussels
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	INISBC-902 Brettanomyces bruxellensis II	This strain is capable of fermenting a beer without the use of a Sacchromyces c.. This yeast produces a beer with a complex flavor profile, containing both fruity and sour notes. 85%+ Attenuation. Low Flocculation. 70-85 F Temperature Range. Medium-High Alcohol Tolerance.
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	INISBC-903 Brettanomyces bruxellensis III	Isolated from a small brewery just outside of Brussels. Produces an aromatic profile that is more mild than INISBC-901 with increased tropical fruitiness. Able to ferment a beer without added Saccharomyces c. Mixed with lactobacillus this strain will create a wonderful sour beer. 90% + Attenuation. Low Flocculation. 60-75 F Temperature Range. High Alcohol Tolerance.	Small Brewery just outside of Brussels
NA	NA	NA	INISBC-913 Brett Barrel Yeast III	Strain is able to ferment without added help from another Saccharomyces c. strain. Produces mild acidity and tropical fruit notes. Leaves the beer with very little mouthfeel. See recipe recommendations for fermentation additions to boost mouthfeel. 90% + Attenuation. Low Flocculation. 60-75 F Temperature Range. High Alcohol Tolerance.	Isolated from a famous american wild ale brewery.
Lambicus	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. lambicus	INISBC-920 Brettanomyces lambicus	Originally isolated from spontaneously fermenting beers, this strain will give your beer textbook Brett flavors like horse blanket and spice, but also fruity notes of pineapple. Fermentation will take well over a month to fully attenuate if used as a primary strain. 85%+ Attenuation. Low Flocculation. 70-85 F Temperature Range. Medium-High Alcohol Tolerance.
Claussenii	Dekkera anomala	B. claussenii	INISBC-930 Brettanomyces claussenii	Possibly the least “Bretty” of the Brettanomyces strains, Claussenii adds great fruity pineapple aroma without the traditional flavors that turn some off from Brett fermented beers. An excellent choice for adding a little funk to your barrel aged favorite. 85%+ Attenuation. Low Flocculation. 85 F+ Temperature Range. Medium-High Alcohol Tolerance.

GigaYeast

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Brussels Bruxellensis GB001	Produces classic Brett “Barnyard” characteristics plus some subtle fruity aroma and moderate acidity. Adds a tart complexity to any beer.
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Tart Cherry Brett GB002	Produces some Brett Barnyard funk plus stone fruit and cherry-like esters. This Strain also produces a moderate amount of acid that adds a tart complexity to the brew.
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Sweet Flemish Brett GB144	Produces a sweet, slightly fruity profile with just a hint of barnyard and spicy phenolics

Jasper Yeast LLC

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis "Chateaux"	JY87	JY87 is a Brettanomyces yeast isolated by jasperyeast LLC. Fast-growing, it has almost Saccharomyces-like doubling times. Shows great fermentation as primary strain in a variety of beers. Ferments fast to 60% attenuation, after which fermentation slows down and more flavor and aroma is produced. Strong pineapple and stonefruit aroma after prolonged fermentations (3-9 months). Great companion to beers that could use some funk, and complements hoppy beers perfectly. Flocculation is low, strain will form a pellicle when oxygen is present. Sequencing of ITS regions indicated Brettanomyces bruxellensis. Micrograph of JY87 cells coming soon.	West-Flanders, Belgium.

Omega Yeast Labs

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma
Claussenii	Dekkera anomala	B. anomala	Brettanomyces claussenii OYL-201	Contributes more Brett aroma than flavor. Fruity, pineapple like aroma. Flocculation: low, Attenuation: 70-85%, Temp: >85°F, Alcohol Toelrance: medium-high, compares to WLP645. Pro brewers only.
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Brettanomyces bruxellensis OYL-202	Medium intensity Brett character. Classic strain used in secondary fermentation for Belgian style beers and lambics. Flocculation: low, Attenuation: 70-85%, Temp: >85°F, Alcohol Tolerance: medium-high, compares to WLP650. Pro brewers only.
Lambicus	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. lambicus	Brettanomyces lambicus OYL-203	This strain has been described as producing horsey, smoky and spicy flavors. As the name suggests, this strain is found most often in Lambic style beers. Flocculation: low, Attenuation: 70-85%, Temp: >85°F, Alcohol Tolerance: medium-high, compares to WLP653. Pro brewers only.

RVA Yeast Labs

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	RVA 502	A medium-intensity Brettanomyces yeast strain. Will add a bit of funk when added during the secondary. Typically used in Belgian-style beers, especially lambic. A famous Trappist brewery produces its unique beer with this yeast during secondary fermentation.
Claussenii	Dekkera anomala	B. claussenii	RVA 501	A low-intensity strain. Contributions from this strain are mostly aromas of pineapple and fruit. This strain prefers higher temperatures (85º F), but will produce nice aroma and subtle flavor at normal ale fermentation termperatures (68-72º F).
Lambicus	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. lambicus	RVA 503	High-intensity “Brett” strain. Very spicey with “smoky” and “horseblanket” flavors and aromas. This strain is used mostly in Lambics and Flanders sour beers.
Unknown	Unknown	Unknown	RVA 804	Produces some amazing aromas of pears, and other fruit esters. We highly recommend this strain for Belgian Dubbels. This strain also makes a very nice cider. A highly flocculating, medium-high attenuating strain adds nice complexity to stouts, and Belgian Ales and Specialty Belgian Ales. Flocculation: Medium, Attenuation: 78-85%, Suggested Temp Range: 65-72°F, Alcohol Tolerance: 14%.	This strain originates from local fruit trees.

White Labs

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	WLP650	Barnyard	Not the same as WY's Brux. Approx. 500 million cells per mL; homebrew vials are approx. 17.5 billion cells at 35 mL ^[97].
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	Brettanomyces bruxellensis Trois Vrai	WLP648	Pear	The vrai (true, in French) Brettanomyces bruxellensis Trois. The infamous strain used for all-Brettanomyces fermentations, has a robust, complex sour character with aromas of pear. Best used as a primary fermentation strain. May be the same as BSI Drie? Profile is very similar to BSI Drie ^[98] ^[99]. Ale of the Riverwards sensory analysis suggests they may be different strains. Approx. 500 million cells per mL; homebrew vials are approx. 17.5 billion cells at 35 mL ^[97].
Claussenii	Dekkera anomala	B. claussenii	WLP645	Fruity, pineapple.	Approx. 500 million cells per mL; homebrew vials are approx. 17.5 billion cells at 35 mL ^[97].
Lambicus	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. lambicus	WLP653	Horsey, Smoky, Spicy.	Different from WY's "lambicus". Approx. 500 million cells per mL; homebrew vials are approx. 17.5 billion cells at 35 mL ^[97].

Wyeast

Common Name	Species Name	Synonym (Strain) Name	Lab/Package	Flavor/Aroma	Source Note
Anomalus	Dekkera anomala	B. anomalus	Wyeast		bottled stout - Burton on Trent, England. Discontinued. Cell count: 7.5 x 10⁸ cells/mL ^[100].
Bruxellensis	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. bruxellensis	Wyeast 5112	"sweaty horse blanket"	Not the same as WL's Brux. Cell count: 7.5 x 10⁸ cells/mL ^[100].
Claussennii	Dekkera anomala	B. claussenii	Wyeast 5151	Notes of tropical fruit, pineapple and, to a lesser extent, peach and blueberry round out a classic Brett profile. Produces “horse blanket,” leathery, and smoky character, but at lower level than other Brett strains. Can be used as the primary strain for fermenting, but is often used after a primary fermentation with an S. cerevisiae strain, and in blends to produce sour beers. It is highly attenuative, given proper time to fully ferment out, and is known to create a pellicle during fermentation.	Private collection for Spring 2015. Cell count: 7.5 x 10⁸ cells/mL ^[100].
Lambicus	Dekkera bruxellensis	B. lambicus	Wyeast 5526	Pie-cherry	Different from WL's "lambicus". Cell count: 7.5 x 10⁸ cells/mL ^[100].

Smaller Labs

Mfg	Package	Notes
BKYeast	Brett X1	Suspected Brettanomyces Anomalus
BKYeast	Brett C1	Isolate from Cantillon Iris
BKYeast	Brett C2	Isolate from Cantillon Iris
BKYeast	Brett C3	Isolate from Cantillon Iris
Craft Cultures	CCYL410 Razz Brettanomyces™	Michigan indigenous. The Razz Brettanomyces™ is the first in a series of indigenous Michigan bacteria. This bacteria was isolated from a wild razz berry in Michigan's Upper Peninsula along the shore of the Portage Lake near Houghton Michigan. Great for use in secondary fermentation for Belgian style beers and lambics. Commercial pitches only.
DCYeast	DCY01
Saccharolicious	Brett I	Brettanomyces yeast from a Walloon Trappist brewery that gives an earthy aroma to the beer. Recommended for secondary fermentation after primary fermentation with Trappist O.
Saccharolicious	Brett II	Fruity Brettanomyces yeast strain with an aroma that reminds of French cider. originates from Brasserie à Vapeur in Pipaix, Belgium, and was isolated from a bottle of Cochonne.

Brett Blends (Brett only)

Manufacturer	Package	Notes
East Coast Yeast	ECY34 Dirty Dozen Brett Blend	Twelve (12) different isolates of Brettanomyces exhibiting high production of barnyard "funk" and esters. Dryness, ripe fruit, and acidity will be encountered over a period of months and over time (>1 yr), may display gueuze-like qualities in complexity. Contains various isolates from lambic-producers, B. bruxellensis, B. anomala, B. lambicus, and B. naardenensis. For those who want the most from Brett yeast, whether a 100% Brett fermentation is desired or adding to secondary aging projects. Suggested fermentation temperature: 60-74 F. Attenuation high.
GigaYeast	Brux Blend (GB156)	A blend of Brettanomyces yeast that produces stone fruit esters and a hint of barnyard. Creates a moderate amount of acid that adds a tart complexity to the brew.
Omega Yeast Labs	All The Bretts OYL-218	This will be an evolving blend comprised of nearly every Brettanomyces strain in our collection (inaugural release will contain 12 strains). When used in secondary, expect high attenuation and a fruity and funky complexity developing over time. Attenuation: 85+%; Flocculation: low; Temperature: 68F-85F. Homebrew pitch contains ~70 billion cells ^[101].
The Yeast Bay	Beersel	Not overly funky but there is a sweaty note hanging behind lemon and citrus fruits, nice blend of subtle funk and citrus/fruit. All strains were identified as B. bruxellensis ^[102].
The Yeast Bay	Brussels	Similar to Beersel but with more funk in aroma and less fruit, complex barnyard character. All strains were identified as B. bruxellensis ^[102].
The Yeast Bay	Lochristi	Smells of Iris C2, probably the same, subtle blend with some delicate fruit, strawberry. All strains were identified as B. bruxellensis ^[102].
The Yeast Bay	Amalgamation Brett Super Blend	6 Brett blend to create a dry beer with a bright and complex fruit-forward flavor and aroma, accompanied by some funk. All strains were identified as B. bruxellensis ^[102].

Using Brett

Primary versus Secondary Fermentation

Brettanomyces can be pitched into a beer at many points in the beer's fermentation life cycle. If used as the primary fermenter, the beer that is produced is often fruit forward and not very funky. A large cell count will be needed (somewhere between an ale and lager pitching rate). See the 100% Brettanomyces Fermentation page for more information. If pitched into a beer that has already been fermented by Saccharomyces, a wider range of flavors including the funkier flavors can be produced (see the Brettanomyces Metabolism section above). A small cell count of Brettanomyces is plenty for creating these flavors, and normally a starter is not necessary. See the Mixed Fermentation and Funky Mixed Fermentations pages for more information on using Brett in secondary.

Starter Information

When pitching just Brettanomyces from a commercial pure or blended culture and no other microbes, it is recommended to make a starter for the culture. If the Brettanomyces is being pitched into secondary, no starter is necessary unless the brewer suspects that the Brettanomyces has lost a lot of viability due to age, heat exposure, etc., or prefers higher cell count pitches.

Two Approaches to Starters

There are generally two approaches to handling Brettanomyces starters. The first is to use a stir plate set to a medium-high RPM with tin foil on top of the flask for 7-8 days, cold crash for a few days, and then decant the beer before pitching the sedimented yeast. The second approach is to use an orbital shaker set to 80 RPM to create a semi-aerobic environment (this means that the oxygen levels are low, but also not non-existent) for 7-8 days as described in The Brettanomyces project ^[103], cold crashing can be skipped, and the entire starter is pitched into the wort. An alternative to the second approach is to use a stir plate on a very low setting so that only a very small "dimple" of a vortex is formed ^[104]. If a stir plate is not available, give the starter an initial dosage of pure O2, and then cover it with foil so that oxygen can slowly diffuse into the starter, and gently agitate as often as possible ^[105].

Oxygen levels are an important factor to consider when deciding which of the above two methods to use for a Brettanomyces starter. Brettanomyces creates acetic acid in the presence of oxygen, potentially leading to higher levels of ethyl acetate, which is considered an off flavor in higher amounts. As the amount of oxygen increases, cell growth increases, but so does acetic acid production. The amount of acetic acid produced is species/strain dependent, so some strains may benefit from more aeration without having the negative effect of creating too much acetic acid. Other strains may need a less aerobic starter (semi-aerobic) in order to produce the highest cell count with minimal acetic acid ^[106]^[107]^[108].

This presents a sort of "catch 22" when growing Brettanomyces in a starter. The brewer must weigh the pros and cons of how much aeration to provide. If the Brettanomyces is going to be used in a 100% Brettanomyces Fermentation, for example, then a stir plate may be the best choice. If the Brettanomyces is instead being pitched in secondary with the intention of long aging, then having a high cell count isn't as necessary and the risk of adding more acetic acid/ethyl acetate to an aging beer is greater. If a lot of acetic acid is produced during the starter, it is advised to cold crash and decant the starter. Brettanomyces can have a difficult time flocculating and settling out, even when cold crashed. The brewer may need to allow a few days for the cells to fully sediment ^[109]. Additionally, Brettanomyces that is cold crashed may be slower to begin fermentation. If the brewer believes that the amount of acetic acid produced was insignificant, then cold crashing can be skipped and the entire starter can be pitched.

Although more experiments and probably needed, agitation is believed to be an important factor for any species of microbe (yeast and bacteria). Gentle stirring on a stir plate or orbital shaker, or frequent gentle manual agitation leads to faster growth and a higher number of organisms. Agitation keeps the microbes in solution. It also maximizes the microbes' access to nutrients and disperses waste evenly. In a non-agitated starter, the microbes are limited to the diffusion rate of nutrients, leading to a slower and more stressful growth ^[110].

Maintaining a temperature of 70°-80°F/20°-26°C should be adequate for most strains. Brettanomyces cell growth typically takes about 7-8 days to reach it's maximum growth ^[111]. Thus, each step of a starter for Brett should be 7-8 days.

For more information regarding aeration and agitation effects on Brettanomyces growth, see Mark Trent's Brettanomyces Propagation Experiment.

Pitching Rate Calculators

Current yeast pitching calculators for brewers are not adequate for determining Brettanomyces pitching rates based on starter volume size because the maximum cell density of Brettanomyces per mL of wort is 3 to 6 times the cell density of Saccharomyces. For example, a given Saccharomyces strain may reach a cell density of 130 million cells per mL in a 1.040 wort (different Saccharomyces strains can have different cell densities as well, although they are a lot lower than Brettanomyces overall). Different Brettanomyces strain cell densities have been reported to be 600 to 885 million cells per mL in 1.040 wort depending on the species/strain ^[111]^[112]. Since yeast calculators are based off of Sacch cell density, using one of these tools for Brettanomyces starters will create an unexpectedly high cell count in reality. There is not currently enough data to accurately determine starter volumes for Brettanomyces, particularly because each strain and species has a different maximum cell density per mL of wort. However, pitching around 500-600 mL of a Brettanomyces starter for 5 gallons of 1.060 SG wort will achieve a pitching rate that is similar to lager yeast pitching rates, which has been recommended for 100% Brettanomyces Fermentation. Omega Yeast Labs is currently working on a project to create a more accurate Brettanomyces pitching rate calculator (it will also contain pitching rate calculations for specific strains of Saccharomyces, which is something that current yeast pitching calculators do not include) ^[112].

Given this information, many brewers historically have been using the lager pitching rate settings in online yeast pitching calculators for Brettanomyces starters (around 2000 mL, for example). Effectively, this means they have been pitching around 4 to 5 times the amount of Brettanomyces cells that they thought they were pitching. However, if this very high pitching rate is giving good results for brewers, it should continued to be used. Exploration of Brettanomyces pitching rates for 100% Brett fermentations is something to be desired once we know what our pitching rates actually are, and many brewers have been pitching 4-5 times the pitching rate for lagers if they use an online yeast pitching rate calculator instead of counting the cells under a microscope.

MYPG Growth Substrate

For yeast laboratories, "Malt Yeast Peptone Glucose" growth substrate has been shown to be a better substrate than wort for initially growing Brettanomyces from a plate or slant. When grown in wort, Brettanomyces will often go through a 24 hour lag phase, a growth phase, another lag phase, and a second growth phase (all within 7-8 days). When grown in MYPG substrate, there is only a single growth phase and no lag phase, which has been reported by Yakobson to produce a larger cell count in the same amount of time ^[113]. Cells grown in MYPG also are better adapted to grow in wort ^[114]. Practical instructions for making this substrate can be found on Jason Rodriguez's blog, "Brew Science - Homebrew Blog". Unfortunately, growing Brettanomyces pitches in MYPG for breweries isn't very practical due to needing almost 4 times the amount of MYPG versus wort to get the same pitching rate. In a brewery or homebrewery, using wort for Brettanomyces starters is more practical ^[115].

Example of a Homemade Orbital Shaker

Mark Trent's shaker platform (obtained from a used equipment outlet in Gilroy, CA called "Outback Equipment" ) used to create a semi-aerobic environment for Brettanomyces. Mark built an insulated box for it, and added temperature control. He can propagate up to 7 liters. This is running at 80 RPM as described in The Brettanomyces project ^[103]^[116].

Storing Brett

Major yeast labs will often freeze yeast in liquid nitrogen using cryopreservation, however this option is generally not practical for brewers ^[117]. The next best option for long term storage of Brettanomyces is freezing with 10% glycerol. If glycerol usage is not an option for the brewer, then slants can provide storage for a few months up to 2+ years, depending on the type of slant used (using mineral oil in slants has been shown to extend the life of stored yeast). For instructions on how to make slants at home capable of storing any microbe for potentially 2+ years, see Bryan's video on Sui Generis Brewing (requires a pressure cooker). Agar plates are the least best solution and have been observed anecdotally to reduce viability of Brettanomyces over a few months ^[118]^[119].

Regarding temperature, it has been shown that cold storage for as long as a month is better than room temperature storage for the same time. The optimal temperature storage periods of time longer than a month are not known. Chad Yakobson noted that after storing Brettanomyces in a refrigerated environment (we don't know how Chad was storing the Brettanomyces cultures when he observed this, for example on agar plates or slants or something else.), after 6 months the Brettanomyces would die. If Brettanomyces is stored cold, it will be very sluggish and slow to start fermentation. Non-pure cultures (such as beer bottle dregs with Brettanomyces in it) should be stored refrigerated. Making a starter is highly recommended if the Brettanomyces culture has been stored cold ^[120].

Richard Preiss's results of storing Brett at different temperatures

Mark Trent repeated Richard Preiss's results of storing Brett at different temperatures, and also in different mediums.

Yakobson's observations were not scientifically quantified and details of his process are lacking (how was the Brettanomyces stored?), as far as we know. Richard Preiss of Escarpment Labs shared the results of a controlled experiment on MTF that showed that BSI's Brett brux Drie and WLP645 B. claussenii survived better in low ABV beer when stored at refrigeration temperatures rather than room temperatures for one month. The samples were grown in 1.040 DME wort until typical cell density was reached, and measured for >95% viability after growth with trypan blue stain and microscopy. 10ml samples of each were stored in sterile conical tubes for one month at different temperatures (4°C and 24°C). The samples were burped to avoid having head pressure as a variable. Trypan blue stain and microscopy were used to measure the viability after one month. After one month of storage at 4°C (39.2°F), the viability of B. claussenii was 92%, and BSI Drie was 72% viability. The samples stored for one month at 24°C (75.2°F) showed a significant drop in viability, with B. claussenii ending up at 40% and BSI Drie at 6% viability. This experiment also indicates that the viability of Brettanomyces strains/species after storage is strain/species dependent ^[121].

Mark Trent repeated Richard Preiss's experiment, but tested different mediums (wort, liquid MYPG, and water). Two Brettanomyces isolates, one from Orval and one from SARA Bernice, were grown in 10 degree Plato wort and MYPG. The isolates are labeled on the chart as "Brett O (Orval)" and "Brett T (Tim Clifford)" respectively. After growth was complete, 10 mL of aliquots were aseptically transferred to 15 mL centrifuge tubes. In addition, the Orval isolate was grown on a MYPG plate and 3 single colonies for each treatment were transferred to 1 mL of sterile RO water in a 2 mL glass tube. Each treatment was prepared in a duplicate and stored at either 22°C or 1°C. Viability was measured after 31 days. Data shown in the chart to the right. No other statistics were performed (there were no statistically significant differences between the different types of storage mediums at room temperature). All storage mediums shared results similar to Richard's results. This further shows that Brettanomyces survival is a function of temperature, with lower temperatures being beneficial towards survival ^[122]. It appears from these experiments that Brettanomyces stores better cold, at least for a ~1 month duration.

Questions raised by MTF members in regards to these results:

How does warm storage versus cold storage affect slants?
Are there any unexpected results if the samples are stored longer (Richard will update), and would this change if the Brettanomyces is periodically fed new sugars? Update: new information on storing Brettanomyces for 6 months at cold vs room temperatures and MYPG vs wort in this MTF thread from Mark Trent. This data appears to show that at 6 months Brettanomcyes survives better in room temperature MYPG vs cold temperature MYPG or cold/room temperature wort. pH may have an effect as well, but more investigation is needed.
How come using dregs from commercial beers stored at room temperature gives good results for brewers?

Tips From Brewers

The Yeast Bay Lochristi Brett Blend

Both Ed Coffey and Amos Browne have noted that this blend ages particularly well.

To make a starter for the Lochristi blend, run it semi-aerobic for 4-6 days in the 70's and then let it settle at room temp and decant what you can if the starter is large ^[123].

References

[1] Wikipedia. Brettanomyces. Retrieved 2/24/2015.

[2] "Improvements in and connected with the Manufacture of English Beers or Malt Liquors and in the Production of Pure Yeast Cultures for use therein." Patent application by Hjelte Claussen for Brettanomyces. A.D. 1903.

[Schifferdecker-3] 3.0 ^3.1 ^3.2 ^3.3 The wine and beer yeast Dekkera bruxellensis. Anna Judith Schifferdecker, Sofia Dashko, Olena P. Ishchuk, and Jure Piškur. 7 July 201.

[Steensels-4] 4.0 ^4.1 ^4.2 ^4.3 ^4.4 Brettanomyces yeasts — From spoilage organisms to valuable contributors to industrial fermentations. Jan Steensels, Luk Daenen, Philippe Malcorps, Guy Derdelinckx, Hubert Verachtert, Kevin J. Verstrepen. International Journal of Food Microbiology Volume 206, 3 August 2015, Pages 24–38.

[5] Screening of yeast mycoflora in winery air samples and their risk of wine contamination. E. Ocón, P. Garijo, S. Sanz, C. Olarte, R. López, P. Santamaría, A.R. Gutiérrez. Food Control Volume 34, Issue 2, December 2013, Pages 261–267.

[yakobson_introduction-6] 6.0 ^6.1 ^6.2 Yakobson, Chad. The Brettanomyces Project. Introduction. Retrieved 8/11/2015.

[7] Wines and Vines. New Research on Role of Yeast in Winemaking; report on a presentation by David Mills and Lucy Joseph from UC Davis. 11/14/2014. Retrieved 08/16/2015.

[8] Removal of Brettanomyces Bruxellensis from Red Wine Using Membrane Filtration. Umiker, Descenzo, Lee, and Edwards. 04/24/2012.

[9] Insight into the Dekkera anomala YV396 genome. Samuel Aeschlimann. Self published on Eureka Brewing Blog. Spet 2015.

[Crauwels1-10] 10.0 ^10.1 ^10.2 ^10.3 Comparative phenomics and targeted use of genomics reveals variation in carbon and nitrogen assimilation among different Brettanomyces bruxellensis strains. S. Crauwels, A. Van Assche, R. de Jonge, A. R. Borneman, C. Verreth, P. Troels, G. De Samblanx, K. Marchal, Y. Van de Peer, K. A. Willems, K. J. Verstrepen, C. D. Curtin, B. Lievens. 2015

[ucdavis_chemwiki-11] 11.0 ^11.1 "Disaccharides." UC Davis Chemwiki. Retrieved 05/15/2016.

[12] Daenen et al., 2008. Evaluation of the glycoside hydrolase activity of a Brettanomyces strain on glycosides from sour cherry (Prunus cerasus L.) used in the production of special fruit beers. FEMS Yeast Res. 8, 1103-1114.

[13] Lance Shaner experiment comparing the growth of various Brettanomyces spp on different growth mediums. 04/07/2016.

[ncyc_searchbrett-14] 14.0 ^14.1 National Collection of Yeast Cultures. Search for Brettanomyces. Retrieved 04/07/2016.

[15] "Sugar composition of wort". Eureka Brewing Blog. Jan 13, 2015. Retrieved 04/07/2016.

[16] Determination of sugar metabolism profiles of non-traditional yeasts in the Saccharomyces and Brettanomyces families. J. D. Cook, W. A. DEUTSCHMAN. ASBC Proceeding. 2015.

[17] Linalool in Hops. MBAA. Stefan Hanke, University Weihenstephan, Germany. 2009.

[18] Monoterpene alcohols release and bioconversion by Saccharomyces species and hybrids. A. Gamero, P. Manzanares, A. Querol, C. Belloch. 2011.

[Daenen2-19] 19.0 ^19.1 Evaluation of the glycoside hydrolase activity of aBrettanomyces strain on glycosides from sour cherry (Prunus cerasus L.) used in the production of special fruit beers. Luk Daenen, Femke Sterckx, Freddy R. Delvaux, Hubert Verachtert & Guy Derdelinckx. 2007.

[20] "Hotrienol." The Good Scents Company. Retrieved 05/11/2016.

[21] "Nerol Oxide." The Good Scents Company. Retrieved 05/11/2016.

[22] De novo synthesis of monoterpenes by Saccharomyces cerevisiae wine yeasts. Francisco M. Carrau, Karina Medina, Eduardo Boido, Laura Farina, Carina Gaggero, Eduardo Dellacassa, Giuseppe Versini, Paul A. Henschke. 2005.

[23] "Glycoside." New World Encyclopedia. Retrieved 05/06/2016.

[Winterhalter-24] 24.0 ^24.1 ^24.2 ^24.3 ^24.4 ^24.5 "Glycoconjugated aroma compounds: Occurrence, role and biotechnological transformation." Peter Winterhalter, George K. Skouroumounis. 1997.

[Maicas-25] 25.0 ^25.1 ^25.2 ^25.3 ^25.4 "Hydrolysis of terpenyl glycosides in grape juice and other fruit juices: a review." Sergi Maicas, José Juan Mateo. May 2005.

[Mansfield-26] 26.0 ^26.1 ^26.2 ^26.3 Quantification of Glycosidase Activities in Selected Strains of Brettanomyces bruxellensis and Oenococcus oeni. A. K. Mansfield, B. W. Zoecklein and R. S. Whiton. 2001.

[27] A survey of glycosidase activities of commercial wine strains of Oenococcus oeni. Antonio Grimaldi, Eveline Bartowsky, Vladimir Jiranek. 2005.

[Daenen1-28] 28.0 ^28.1 ^28.2 ^28.3 Screening and evaluation of the glucoside hydrolase activity in Saccharomyces and Brettanomyces brewing yeasts. L. Daenen, D. Saison, F. Sterckx, F.R. Delvaux, H. Verachtert, G. Derdelinckx. 2007.

[29] "Linalool." The Good Scents Company. Retrieved 05/12/2016.

[30] "Methyl salicylate." Chemistry World. Retrieved 05/12/2016.

[31] "1-octen-3-ol." The Good Scents Company. Retrieved 05/12/2016.

[32] "(Z)-3-hexen-1-ol." The Good Scents Company. Retrieved 05/12/2016.

[33] World Brewing Congress, 2008. Pg 80. Retrieved 05/13/2016.

[34] Quantification of glycosidase activities in selected yeasts and lactic acid bacteria. H McMahon, B W Zoecklein, K Fugelsang, Y Jasinski. 1999.

[35] Wikipedia. Secondary Metabolite. Retrieved 6/2/2015.

[36] Yakobson, Chad. Pure Culture Fermentation Characteristics of Brettanomyces Yeast Species and Their Use in the Brewing Industry. Production of Secondary Metabolites. 2011.

[37] "Thoughts on Spitaels and Van Kerrebroeck et al, 2015." Dave Janssen. Hors Catégorie Blog. 02/20/2016. Retrieved 03/15/2016.

[Spaepen-38] 38.0 ^38.1 ^38.2 ^38.3 Spaepen and Verachtert, 1982. Esterase Activity in the Genus Brettanomyces

[MTF_Brett_Secondary-39] 39.0 ^39.1 ^39.2 Brettanomyces secondary fermentation experiment. Milk The Funk Wiki. Lance Shaner and Richard Preiss. Retrieved 04/21/2016.

[40] PubChem. Ethyl Acetate. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[41] Ethyl Butyrate Beer Flavour Standard. FlavorActIV. Retrieved 6/20/2015.

[42] Flavoractiv. Ethyl butyrate. Retrieved 1/18/2015.

[pubchem_ethylbutyrate-43] 43.0 ^43.1 PubChem. Ethyl Butyrate. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[yakobson1-44] 44.0 ^44.1 ^44.2 ^44.3 ^44.4 ^44.5 ^44.6 ^44.7 ^44.8 ^44.9 Yakobson, Chad. Pure Culture Fermentation Characteristics of Brettanomyces Yeast Species and Their Use in the Brewing Industry. Pure Culture Fermentation Discussion. 2011.

[45] Encyclopedia of Food Microbiology. Batt, Carl A. Academic Press. Sep 28, 1999. Pg 320.

[46] Aroxa. ethyl hexanoate. Retrieved 1/18/2015.

[47] PubChem. Ethyl Caproate. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[48] Chemspider. Ethylhexanoat. Retrieved 1/18/2015.

[49] Ethyl Octanoate. The Good Scents Company. Retrieved 5/28/2015.

[50] Chop & Brew - Episode 37: Influence of Mashing on Sour Beer Production by Michael Tonsmeire. NHC 2014 Presentation. At 26 minutes. Retrieved 5/28/2015.

[51] Esters Detection Tresholds & Molecular Structures. Leffingwell & Associates. Retrieved 5/28/2015.

[pubchem_ethylcaprylate-52] 52.0 ^52.1 PubChem. Ethyl Caprylate. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[wikipedia_ethyldecanoate-53] 53.0 ^53.1 Wikipedia. Ethyl Decanoate. Retrieved 1/18/2015.

[54] Flavours and Fragrances: Chemistry, Bioprocessing and Sustainability. Ralf Günter Berger. Springer Science & Business Media, Mar 6, 2007. Pg 222.

[55] Spedding, Gary. Flavor notes for Michigan Craft Guild Conference. 2014.

[Fenaroli_ethylisovalerate-56] 56.0 ^56.1 ^56.2 ^56.3 Fenaroli's Handbook of Flavor Ingredients, Fifth Edition. George A. Burdock. CRC Press, Dec 3, 2004. Pg 587.

[Joseph-57] 57.0 ^57.1 ^57.2 ^57.3 Supplemental Data for: Joseph, C.M.L., E.A. Albino, S.E. Ebeler, and L.F. Bisson. Brettanomyces bruxellensis aroma-active compounds determined by SPME GC-MS olfactory analysis. 2015.

[lucy_joseph-58] 58.0 ^58.1 Impact of Brettanomyces on Wine. Presentation by Lucy Joseph of UC Davis. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[59] Best Aroma website. Ethyl Lactate. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[60] Dictionary of Flavors. Dolf De Rovira. John Wiley & Sons, Feb 28, 2008. Pg 384.

[61] Haz-Map, Ethyl Lactate odor threshold.

[62] PubChem. Ethyl Lactate. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[63] Yakobson, Chad. The Brettanomyces Project. Impact of the Initial Concentration of Lactic Acid on Pure Culture Fermentation. Retrieved 6/16/2015.

[goodscents_ethylvalerate-64] 64.0 ^64.1 ^64.2 The Good Scents Company. Ethyl Valerate article. Retrieved 08/15/2015. Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "goodscents_ethylvalerate" defined multiple times with different content

[Fenaroli_ethylvalerate-65] 65.0 ^65.1 Fenaroli's Handbook of Flavor Ingredients, Fifth Edition. George A. Burdock. CRC Press, Dec 3, 2004. Pg 638.

[66] Organoleptic Threshold Values of Some Organic Acids in Beer. Sigmund Engan. 1973.

[67] Aroma of Beer, Wine and Distilled Alcoholic Beverages. L. Nykänen, H. Suomalainen. Springer Science & Business Media, May 31, 1983.

[68] Aroxa. Isaoamyl acetate. Retrieved 1/18/2015.

[69] PubChem. Isoamyl Acetate. Retrieved 08/25/2015.

[70] PubChem. Phenethyl Acetate. Retrieved 08/15/2015.

[71] YMDB. Phenethyl acetate.

[72] Burdock, George A. Fenaroli's Handbook of Flavor Ingredients, Fifth Edition. CRC Press. 2005. pg 1521.

[73] Characterization of aroma and flavor compounds present in lambic (gueuze) beer. Katherine A Thompson Witrick. 2012.

[Lentz-74] 74.0 ^74.1 ^74.2 Analysis of Growth Inhibition and Metabolism of Hydroxycinnamic Acids by Brewing and Spoilage Strains of Brettanomyces Yeast. Michael Lentz and Chad Harris. 2015.

[Doss-75] 75.0 ^75.1 ^75.2 ^75.3 ^75.4 ^75.5 Doss, Greg. Brettanomyces: Flavors and performance of single and multiple strain fermentations with respect to time. Presentation at 2008 NHC. pg 12.

[Yakobson_Michigan-76] 76.0 ^76.1 ^76.2 ^76.3 ^76.4 ^76.5 Yakobson, Chad. Brettanomyces in Brewing the horse the goat and the barnyard. 1/14/2011

[77] Determination of 4-vinylgaiacol and 4-vinylphenol in top-fermented wheat beers by isocratic high performance liquid chromatography with ultraviolet detector. Mingguang Zhu; Yunqian Cui. Dec 2013.

[goodscents_4VP-78] The Good Scents Company. 4-Vinylphenol. Retrieved 08/18/2015.

[Oelofse-79] 79.0 ^79.1 ^79.2 Molecular identification of Brettanomyces bruxellensis strains isolated from red wines and volatile phenol production. A. Oelofse, A. Lonvaud-Funel, M. du Toit. 2009.

[80] Aroxa Website. 4-Vinylguaiacol. Retrieved 08/19/2015.

[goodscents_4VG-81] 81.0 ^81.1 The Good Scents Company. 2-methoxy-4-vinyl phenol. Retrieved 08/18/2015.

[82] Ferulic Acid Release and 4-Vinylguaiacol Formation during Brewing and Fermentation: Indications for Feruloyl Esterase Activity in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Stefan Coghe, Koen Benoot, Filip Delvaux, Bart Vanderhaegen, and Freddy R. Delvaux. 2004.

[83] The biotransformation of simple phenolic compounds by Brettanomyces anomalus. Duncan A.N. Edlin1, Arjan Narbad, J. Richard Dickinson1 andDavid Lloyd. 2006.

[84] PubChem. 3-Vinylcatechol. Retrieved 08/18/2015.

[85] Aroxa Website. 4-Ethyl Phenol. Retrieved 08/19/2015.

[Maarse-86] 86.0 ^86.1 Volatile Compounds in Foods and Beverages. Henk Maarse. CRC Press, Mar 29, 1991. Pg 514, 515.

[pubchem_4EP-87] 87.0 ^87.1 PubChem Website. 4-Ethylphenol. Retrieved 08/19/2015.

[88] Aroxa Website. 4-Ethyl guaiacol. Retrieved 08/19/2015.

[pubchem_4EG-89] 89.0 ^89.1 PubChem Website. 4-Ethyl-2-methoxyphenol. Retrieved 08/19/2015.

[PubChem_4EC-90] 90.0 ^90.1 PubChem Website. 4-Ethylcatechol. Retrieved 08/19/2015.

[91] Botha, Janita J. Sensory, chemical and consumer analysis of Brettanomyces spoilage in South African wines. March 2010. Pg 2, 13, 17, 18

[92] Oelofse, Adriaan. Investigating the role of Brettanomyces and Dekkera during winemaking. December 2008.

[93] FlavorActV. Caprylic Acid. Retrieved 2/10/2015.

[94] "Decanoic acid". Wikipedia.

[95] Humbard, Matt. Milk The Funk Discussion. 3/10/2015.

[96] Conversation with Mark Horsley and Ed Coffey on MTF. 02/11/2016.

[reddit_brett-97] 97.0 ^97.1 ^97.2 ^97.3 Homebrewing Reddit post. 02/26/2016.

[98] Ryan Steagall's conversation with White Labs on Facebook. April 10, 2015.

[99] White Labs 644 Explanation. 04/09/2015. Retrieved 5/2/2015.

[wyeast_cellcounts-100] 100.0 ^100.1 ^100.2 ^100.3 Wyeast Specifications 2015 Retail Products. 2015.

[101] Conversation with Lance Shaner on MTF regarding Omega cell counts. 10/09/2015.

[TYB_Blends-102] 102.0 ^102.1 ^102.2 ^102.3 Conversation with Nick Impellitteri regarding taxonomy of the TYB Brett blends. 11/13/2015.

[chad_rpm-103] 103.0 ^103.1 Yakobson, Chad. The Brettanomyces Project. Propagation and Batch Culture Methods. Retrieved 2/18/2015.

[104] Conversation with Mark Trent, Richard Preiss, and Roy Ventullo on MTF regarding creating a semi-aerobic starter without an orbital shaker. 11/06/2015

[105] Conversation with Nick Impellitteri on MTF in regards to semi-aerobic starters. 2/16/2015.

[106] Brettanomyces bruxellensis: effect of oxygen on growth and acetic acid production. Aguilar Uscanga, Délia1, and Strehaiano. 2003.

[107] Role of oxygen on acetic acid production by Brettanomyces/Dekkera in winemaking. Maurizio Ciani and Luisa Ferraro. April 1999.

[108] Acetic acid production by Dekkera/Brettanomyces yeasts. S.N. Feer. April 2002.

[109] Conversation with Richard Preiss of Escarpment Yeast Labs on MTF. 6/26/2015.

[110] Conversation with Bryan of Sui Generis Blog about starters and agitation. 11/09/2015.

[Yakobson_Propagation-111] 111.0 ^111.1 Yakobson, Chad. The Brettanomyces Project. Propagation and Batch Culture Results. Retrieved 2/17/2015

[MarkTrent-112] 112.0 ^112.1 Conversation with Mark Trent and Lance Shaner on MTF regarding Brett pitching rates. 07-21-2015.

[113] Yakobson, Chad. The Brettanomyces Project. MYPG Compared to Wort as a Growth Substrate. Retrieved 2/18/2015.

[114] Yakobson, Chad. The Brettanomyces Project. Propagation and Batch Culture Discussion. Paragraph 5. Retrieved 2/18/2015.

[115] Conversation with Mark Trent, Lance Shaner, and Richard Preiss on MTF. 09/18/2015.

[116] Discussion with Mark Trent on Milk The Funk. 4/2/2015.

[117] Brewing: New Technologies. Charlie Bamforth. 2006. Pg 170.

[118] Conversation with Matt Humbard, Ritchie Preiss, and Jeff Melo on MTF. 6/4/2015.

[119] Conversation with Nick Impellitteri on MTF regarding storing Brett on agar plates. 7/24/2015.

[120] Yakobson, Chad. Presentation at 2012 Music City Brew Off. At 43:00.

[121] Richard Preiss Brett storage experiment results on MTF. 7/24/2015.

[122] Conversation with Mark Trent on MTF. 09/10/2015.

[123] Nick Impellitteri of The Yeast Bay on a MTF thread. Feb 17, 2015.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]

[20]

[21]

[22]

[23]

[24]

[25]

[26]

[27]

[28]

[29]

[30]

[31]

[32]

[33]

[34]

[35]

[36]

[37]

[38]

[39]

[40]

[41]

[42]

[43]

[44]

[45]

[46]

[47]

[48]

[49]

[50]

[51]

[52]

[53]

[54]

[55]

[56]

[57]

[58]

[59]

[60]

[61]

[62]

[63]

[64]

[65]

[66]

[67]

[68]

[69]

[70]

[71]

[72]

[73]

[74]

[75]

[76]

[77]

[78]

[79]

[80]

[81]

[82]

[83]

[84]

[85]

[86]

[87]

[88]

[89]

[90]

[91]

[92]

[93]

[94]

[95]

[96]

[97]

[98]

[99]

[100]

@@ Line 27: / Line 27: @@
 There is a highly genetic diversity between strains of ''Brettanomyces'' species, both in a [http://www.diffen.com/difference/Genotype_vs_Phenotype genotypic and phenotypic] sense <ref name="Crauwels1">[http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00253-015-6769-9 Comparative phenomics and targeted use of genomics reveals variation in carbon and nitrogen assimilation among different Brettanomyces bruxellensis strains.  S. Crauwels, A. Van Assche, R. de Jonge, A. R. Borneman, C. Verreth, P. Troels, G. De Samblanx, K. Marchal, Y. Van de Peer, K. A. Willems, K. J. Verstrepen, C. D. Curtin, B. Lievens.  2015]</ref>. Not all species are capable of consuming the same types of sugars.  For example, ''B. anomalus'' (aka claussenii) are generally able to ferment lactose, but ''B. bruxellensis'' is generally not.  Different strains within the same species may not be able to ferment the same types of sugars <ref>[https://www.facebook.com/groups/MilkTheFunk/permalink/1279884332039778/ Lance Shaner experiment comparing the growth of various ''Brettanomyces spp'' on different growth mediums.  04/07/2016.]</ref><ref name="ncyc_searchbrett">[https://catalogue.ncyc.co.uk/catalogsearch/result/?q=brettanomyces National Collection of Yeast Cultures.  Search for ''Brettanomyces''.  Retrieved 04/07/2016.]</ref>.  For example, some strains are not able to ferment maltose, which is almost half the sugar content of wort <ref>[https://eurekabrewing.wordpress.com/tag/sugar/ "Sugar composition of wort".  Eureka Brewing Blog.  Jan 13, 2015.  Retrieved 04/07/2016.]</ref>.  Such strains would not be a good choice for [[100%25_Brettanomyces_Fermentation|100% ''Brettanomyces'' fermentation]].
-The ability of a given ''Brettanomyces'' strain to ferment different types of sugars might be at least partially linked to its source.  For example, a strain of ''B. bruxellensis'' isolated from a soft drink could not ferment the disaccharides maltose, turanose, or the trisaccharide melezitose, whereas all of the other ''B. bruxellensis'' strains isolated from beer and wine could ferment these disaccharides/trisaccharide.  The beer strains, however, were unable to ferment cellobiose or gentiobiose, as well as arbutin and methyl-gluoside.  The wine strains were able to ferment these disaccharides, perhaps because they were adapted to the environment in which they were isolated from (wine barrels) <ref name="Crauwels1"></ref>.
+The ability of a given ''Brettanomyces'' strain to ferment different types of sugars might be at least partially linked to its source of isolation.  For example, a strain of ''B. bruxellensis'' isolated from a soft drink could not ferment the disaccharides maltose, turanose, or the trisaccharide melezitose, whereas all of the other ''B. bruxellensis'' strains isolated from beer and wine could ferment these disaccharides/trisaccharide.  The beer strains, however, were unable to ferment cellobiose or gentiobiose, as well as arbutin and methyl-gluoside.  The wine strains were able to ferment these disaccharides, perhaps because they were adapted to the environment in which they were isolated from (wine barrels) <ref name="Crauwels1"></ref>.
 Currently, research into how well ''Brettanomyces'' strains ferment the trisaccharide maltotriose has not been explored much by science, however one study found that ''B. custersianus'' can ferment maltotriose.  Another study found that all 7 strains of ''B. bruxellensis'' tested could ferment maltotriose, but not the trisaccharide raffinose.  More investigation into this possibility is needed <ref>[http://www.asbcnet.org/events/archives/2015Meeting/proceedings/Pages/54.aspx Determination of sugar metabolism profiles of non-traditional yeasts in the Saccharomyces and Brettanomyces families.  J. D. Cook, W. A. DEUTSCHMAN.  ASBC Proceeding.  2015.]</ref><ref name="Crauwels1"></ref>.   The below table is an example of the variety of sugar types that different strains/species of ''Brettanomyces'' banked at the [https://catalogue.ncyc.co.uk National Collection of Yeast Cultures] can ferment:

Ester	Precursors	Flavor/Odor Threshold	Molecular Formula	Notes
Ethyl acetate (fruity, pineapple, solventy)	Acetic Acid and ethanol	33ppm (odor), 100ppm (flavor)	C₄H₈O₂ ^[40]	High flavor threshold; pineapple or pear-like in low amounts and nail polish in high amounts. Increases production with higher temperatures and oxygen.
Ethyl butyrate (pineapple, mango, tropical fruit ^[41])	Butyric Acid and ethanol	0.4ppm (flavor) ^[42]	C₆H₁₂O₂ ^[43]	Low levels of production by some species of Brettanomyces; production decreases with higher acidity ^[44]. Also known as ethyl butanoate ^[43].
Ethyl caproate (sweet, fruity, pineapple, banana, apple or aniseed)	Caproic acid and ethanol ^[45]	0.2ppm (flavor) ^[46]	C₈H₁₆O₂ ^[47]	Also known as Ethyl hexanoate, Ethyl butyl acetate, and butylacetate ^[48]
Ethyl caprylate (Sweet, waxy, fruity and pineapple with creamy, fatty, mushroom and cognac notes ^[49])	Caprylic acid (contained in buckwheat; produced by yeast autolysis) and ethanol ^[50]	15ppb (flavor) ^[51]	C₁₀H₂₀O₂ ^[52]	Also known as ethyl octanoate ^[52].
Ethyl Decanoate (brandy, fruity, oily, grape)	Capric Acid (Decanoic acid) and ethanol ^[53]	0.5ppm (flavor in water) ^[54]	C₁₂H₂₄O₂ ^[53]	Also known as Ethyl caprate, Ethyl caprinate, and Capric acid ethyl ester ^[55]
Ethyl isovalerate (fruity, sweet, berry-like with a ripe, pulpy fruit nuance ^[56]) ^[57]^[58]	Isovaleric Acid and ethanol	30ppm (flavor) ^[56]	C₇H₁₄O₂ (same as ethyl valerate) ^[56]	Also found in pineapple, orange juice and peel oil, bilberry, blueberry, strawberry, Swiss cheese, other cheeses, cognac, rum, whiskey, sherry, grape wines, cocoa, passion fruit, mango, and mussels ^[56]. Also known as Ethyl 3-methylbutanoate ^[57].
Ethyl lactate (fruity, creamy, rum ^[59]^[60])	Lactic Acid and ethanol	0.2 ppm-1.66 ppm (odor) ^[61]	C₅H₁₀O₃ ^[62]	Increases production with higher amounts of Lactic Acid ^[63]
Ethyl valerate (Sweet, fruity, acidic, pineapple, apple, green, berry and tropical ^[64]) ^[57]^[58]	Valeric Acid (pentanoic acid) and ethanol	1500-5000 ppm (odor) ^[65]	C₇H₁₄O₂ ^[64]	Valeric acid quantities found in beer are minimal (0-1 ppm) and below odor threshold ^[66]^[67], and is probably also the case for Ethyl valerate. Ethyl valerate is also known as ethyl pentanoate ^[64]. Also found in apples, bananas, guava, stawberry, cheeses, rum, whiskey, cider, sherry, grape wines, cocoa, coffee, honey, and passion fruit ^[65].
Isoamyl acetate (banana)	Acetic Acid and Isoamyl alcohol	1.1ppm (flavor) ^[68]	C₇H₁₄O₂ ^[69]	Produced by certain Saccharomyces strains but concentrations are generally reduced by Brettanomyces. Brettanomyces produces only very small amounts itself ^[38]
Phenethyl acetate (sweet, honey, rose flower like)	Acetyl-CoA and 2-phenylethanol ^[70]^[71]	3-5ppm (odor), 5-10ppm (flavor) ^[72]	C₁₀H₁₂O₂	Produced in very small amounts in Lambic ^[38]^[73].

Phenol	Phenol Type	Precursors	Flavor/Odor Threshold	Molecular Structure	Notes
4-Vinylphenol ^[75] ^[76] (Barnyard, Medicinal, Band-aid, Plastic)	Vinyl phenol	p-Coumaric Acid	0.2 ppm (flavor; in beer) ^[77]	C₈H₈O ^[78]	Production level is different across species/strains of Brettanomyces ^[79].
4-Vinylguaiacol ^[75]^[76] (Clove)	Vinyl phenol	Ferulic Acid	0.3 ppm (flavor; in beer) ^[80]	Also known as 2-methoxy-4-vinyl phenol ^[81]	C₉H₁₀O₂ ^[81]. Produced by some strains of S. cerevisiae ^[82]. Some Brettanomyces species/strains may also be able to produce this compound at varying levels ^[57]^[83]^[79].
4-Vinylcatechol ^[75]^[76] (Plastic, Bitter, Smokey)	Vinyl phenol	Caffeic Acid		C₈H₈O₂ ^[84]	Production level is difference across species/strains of Brettanomyces ^[79].
4-Ethylphenol ^[75]^[76] (Barnyard, Spicy, Smoky, Medicinal, Band-Aid ^[85])	Ethyl phenol	4-vinylphenol	0.3 ppm (odor; in beer) ^[86]	C₈H₁₀O ^[87]	Also known as 1-Ethyl-4-hydroxybenzene and P-Ethylphenol ^[87].
4-Ethylguaiacol ^[75]^[76] (Smokey, Spicy, Clove ^[88])	Ethyl phenol	4-vinylguaiacol	0.13 ppm (odor; in beer) ^[86]	C₉H₁₂O₂ ^[89]	Also known as 4-Ethyl-2-methoxyphenol ^[89].
4-Ethylcatechol ^[75]^[76] (Band‐aide, Medicinal, Barnyard)	Ethyl phenol	4-Vinylcatechol		C₈H₁₀O₂ ^[90]	Also known as 4-ethylbenzene-1,2-diol ^[90].