Changes

'''Oxidized beta acids''' produce some compounds that also contribute to perception of bitterness, specifically hulupones. Unlike humulinones which form relatively quickly from oxidation of alpha acids, hulupones form at a much slower rate <ref name="Dušek_2014" />. Also unlike humulinones, they survive boiling and fermentation. While some sensory analysis of beers containing oxidized beta acids describe the resulting bitterness as "harsh and clinging", another analysis by Krafta et al (2013) described the bitterness of oxidized beta acids in beer when added in their pure form at the beginning of the boil as "pleasant and not lingering". The more degradation of beta acids into oxidized beta acids that occurs in hops, the more bitter beers brewed with these hops will be <ref name="krofta_2013" />. Two other compounds other than hulupones have been identified as being produced by the oxidation of beta acids, epoxycohulupone and epoxyhulupone. Their effect on beer flavor is not yet known, however it is thought that hulupones have the greatest impact on beer flavor <ref name="Dušek_2014" />.

Both humulinones and hulupones have been identified as forming due to the oxidation of hop acids. However, other researchers have reported that both of these bitter compounds formed during the boiling of hops, and another during the storage and aging of beer. In all cases though the amounts of the compounds directly correlated with the amount of hops used <ref name="Algazzali_2014" />.

Hop oils also generally degrade over time, however their degradation rates are more complex. [http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf00070a043 Lam et al. (1986)] found that aging both cascade and North American grown Hallertauer Mittelfrueh resulted in an increase in grapefruit-like character, although the compound that caused this was not identified. In the case of Cascade the intensity of this flavor correlated with the age of the hops <ref name="Lam et al., 1986"> [http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/jf00070a043 Aging of Hops and Their Contribution to Beer Flavor. Lam et al. 1986.] </ref>. In the Hallertauer hops, aging resulted in an increase in a spicy/herbal character <ref name="Lam et al., 1986"/>, which is in agreement with reports of oxidized sesquiterpenes (specifically humulenol II, humulene diepoxides, caryophyllene, and to a lesser extent humulene monoepoxides and alpha-humulene) contributing a spicy/herbal flavor to beer <ref name="Goiris et al., 2002">[http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/j.2050-0416.2002.tb00129.x/abstract Goiris et al., 2002]</ref><ref name="Mikyška_2012" />. Many of the oils followed in the Lam et al. (1986) study which increased during a short accelerated aging period (2 weeks at 90°F) then decreased during extended aging (60 additional days at 90°F). The cascade hops lost more of the fruity/citrusy hop oils (myrecene, linalool, geranial) than Hallertauer, suggesting that different strains of hops can withstand aging better than others. The concentration of hop oils are affected by the brewing process and fermentation (see the table) <ref name="Lam et al., 1986"/>. Another study found that beta-ionone (classified as a ketone, and characterized as "floral" and "woody" <ref>[http://www.thegoodscentscompany.com/data/rw1006632.html Beta-ionone. Good Scents Company. Retrieved 11/22/2016.]</ref>) increased in beers brewed with hops that were aged for 30 days at 40°C versus beers brewed with aged hops <ref name="kishimoto_2007" />.

* [http://scottjanish.com/increasing-bitterness-dry-hopping/ "Increasing Bitterness By Dry Hopping", article by Scott Janish on oxidized alpha acids.]